Wednesday, April 27, 2011

Imran Khan’s revolution

BY MURTAZA RAZVI ON APRIL 27TH, 2011

Image001
The way Imran Khan has been rallying the youth over the years has now seen him put up a big show in Peshawar over the weekend. “Stop the drone strikes, or we’ll block Nato supplies to Afghanistan!” cried the angry cricketer-turned-philanthropist-turned politician from a stage that seemed more like a pulpit.

Khan is no diplomat; he does not know how to mince words, and believes in thinking aloud at all times. He boots for success and does not know of failure; even when failure strikes, as in his politics over the years, he picks up the pieces and starts walking again.

Nothing seems to bog him down, no obstacle appears insurmountable; he’s in it for the long haul. Add to this the personal charisma that he has carried all these years, and you have an endearing leader in him: relatively young, educated and articulate. He does not do doublespeak nor plays mind games, and is thus also a darling of the youthful electronic media, many of whose not as charismatic talk show hosts have been echoing the same mix of rightist patriotism in a new, empowered lingo. The only problem is that little of it is based on progressive thinking.

Safeguarding national honour is like protecting your women, believing that your honour lies in them, and as your possession, and that they are incapable of protecting it themselves. The truth is that they will remain incapacitated if you do not take steps to educate and emancipate them; make the same tools of life available to them as are to men. The same is true for any nation’s capacity to defend itself and its so-called national honour. Unless a nation has access to the wherewithal of modern life, the right education, a working healthcare system, the social net hedging the less privileged, gainful employment and opportunity for all, it lives a life of utter dishonour and low self-esteem.

It is not the West or the CIA that have done this to us. We’ve worked hard to achieve this ignoble status ourselves. The kind of education we impart, with heavy doses of right-wing rhetoric and a hollow sense of patriotism based on the hatred of others, instead of empirical knowledge and adherence of universal values, produces only bigots. Those not having access even to this shady mix of ideological social engineering then gang up on society to blow up schools, preferably girls’ schools, mosques and shrines alike. That’s their revenge on a society that is working to sully not its own honour but also that of the great Muslim faith, hence there can be no meeting point with them.

They must be eliminated to make room for the pious and the righteous to establish Allah’s writ in this unruly world which is full of evil attractions for the rich; a whole generation of pious sons must be raised, everyone of whom is a mujahid, ready to kill and maim all those who oppose Allah and his Kingdom. The world must be cleansed of all infidels. Muslims not buying into this world view must also be eliminated for they are agents of infidels.
Now this is the emerging world that Imran Khan has set out to turn around on the back of the groundswell of his popularity amongst largely urban youth.

Given the rising anti-US sentiment, mainly in urban Pakistan, and with alleged help from certain powerful quarters that share his vision for an Islamic welfare state, where women and minorities are seen as burden, he is very likely to win more and more converts as he pushes ahead. And the first step in doing so is to cut off Nato’s supplies into Afghanistan, as proposed by him. The next would be to rescind Pakistan’s commitment to being a partner in America’s war on terror, because we’re a state armed with nukes, not Iraq or Afghanistan that could be invaded. In doing so he forgets one critical aspect: who will finance this newfound independence and the flagging about of national honour?

According to the political analyst, Khaled Ahmed, Pakistan only succeeds if it succeeds economically. He goes on to say that our economic success hinges very much on whether we give trade passage to willing, buying countries. This may mean giving passage to India and Central Asia from east to west and vice versa, China from north to south and vice versa, and the US and others as and when they need such a passage through Pakistan. Denying this passage will mean that the international community will have to go around us and make other, perhaps more expensive arrangements, like India has done for its oil supplies.

The US too can bypass Pakistan by exploring more expensive routes for Nato supplies but in the process it can isolate Pakistan completely, and bring its already troubled economy to a grinding halt. It will not need to militarily invade Pakistan, for we will have accomplished the needful ourselves. Where will then the urban youth, and those nouveau riche TV anchors will go to seek their comforts, more opportunities to prosper and live a better, more promising life, with less loadshedding, more air conditioning and international mobility? A revolution to regain national honour by asserting independence in an increasingly interdependent world will surely result in economic blockade and a nation so inclined left to rot in its own isolation, making it all the more irrelevant to the rest of the world. Drone attacks must stop but we have to remove the bait that brings them on in the first place.

In order to start putting things right, one does not start by blocking the roads or threatening to march on the capital to bring down an allegedly corrupt and inept government that has failed to deliver. Who else but Imran Khan should know that to treat cancer he had to build a well-equipped modern hospital instead of destroying the ones that were there and could not provide the needed treatment. The positive energy that went into building that state of the art treatment facility is what is required at the national level to start setting things right; an overdose of radical ideology just won’t cut it. It does not get any simpler than that.

Controversies surround population census

The ongoing population census being conducted by the federal government has become controversial right from the start, experts told Pakistan Today. The census is carried out in two phases, starting with house listing which will be followed by a general census. As per the figures from the last census, the total population of the country in March 1998 was 130.58 million, of which Punjab was comprised of 72.5 million, Sindh 29.9 million, NWFP 15.5 million, Balochistan 6.5 million and Fata 3.1 million. 

Read more...

Secret Files: Algerian Double Agent was on British, Canadian Payroll

Secret Files: Algerian Involved in US Consulate Attack in Peshawar was on British, Canadian Payroll Wednesday, 27 April 2011 06:34Joseph Hannan E-mailPrintPDF Files reveal Adil Hadi was on payroll of British, Canadian secret services. PHOTO: AFP/FILE

At least one Guantanamo Bay detainee discovered to be involved in a plot to attack the US Consulate in Peshawar and believed to have carried out a string of bombings in Pakistan in 2002, was also on the payroll for British and Canadian intelligence services, according to secret files on detainees at the Guantanamo Bay prison camp.

Algerian detainee Adil Hadi al Jazairi bin Hamili, linked with the Algerian Armed Islamic Group and the Hezb-e-Islami Gulbuddin, confessed that he had worked for the Taliban’s foreign ministry and intelligence services as well.

Read more...

The plight of child housekeepers

HOME WORK

On February 11, 2010, Yasmin, a 15-year-old girl was allegedly burnt by her employers in Okara and died five days later in a hospital in Lahore. Her father weeping at the memory of his young daughter revealed later that this was not the first instance of violence at the hands of Yasmin’s employers. “They used to occasionally beat her up over trivial issues and she would often complain about it. I think we should have just told the police before anything like this happened,” he moaned.

Continue reading The plight of child housekeepers

Fake Degree Holder PPP MNA Praises Acquittal of Rapists!

ISLAMABAD: While there is a hue and cry among NGOs and human rights activists against the Supreme Court judgment in Mukhtaran Mai’s case, there are a few who are ready to welcome the apex court’s decision saying that the courts are dispensing justice even when they are under pressure.

Continue reading Fake Degree Holder PPP MNA Praises Acquittal of Rapists!

Three Cups Of Tea Won’t Be Enough For Pakistan

Nadia Naviwala poses with students on the last day of English summer camp at an NGO-built girls' school in a village on the Pakistan-India border.

Since the publication of Three Cups of Tea, Americans have lavished nearly $60 million on Greg Mortenson’s Central Asia Institute, to build schools in Afghanistan and Pakistan. Last week, four years after the book came out, someone — CBS’s 60 Minutes — finally visited the schools that Mortenson claims to have built, and found many empty, misused or nonexistent.

Reading about the extent of financial irregularity and lack of oversight at CAIis heartbreaking. But worse, I dread how the crumbling of Three Cups of Tea will reinforce American skepticism and Pakistani cynicism about positive efforts in the region.

Continue reading Three Cups Of Tea Won’t Be Enough For Pakistan

Tennis under a cloud of drones?

In a bid to bring sporting action to war-stricken Waziristan, the Pakistan Tennis Federation (PTF) is planning to hold an event in the mountainous region featuring top national players of the country, according to the federation’s secretary.


Waziristan has been affected by drone attacks since the start of war against terrorism and Taliban resurgence. Well aware of the dangers the area possesses, the PTF has started preparations for holding an event in the region.

Continue reading Tennis under a cloud of drones?

A major blow to curbing violence against women

The Supreme Court’s (SC) acquittal of men who gang-raped Mukhtaran Mai some nine years ago has not only caused heartfelt dejection for many, but it can haveserious broader implications. It is feared that such a decision will only add to the existing on-ground difficulties faced by rape and other gender violence victims in our country. It is also not unreasonable to suspect that perpetrators of crimes against women will become even more confident of getting away without due punishment.

Continue reading A major blow to curbing violence against women

Plan afoot to establish nine food streets

Gawalmandi

After the demise of Gawalmandi Food Street owing to political pressure in 2008, the Punjab government has planned to set up nine food streets to appease the traditional and continental food lovers, Pakistan Today has learnt. According to the plan, the proposed food streets will be established in Gulberg, Shalimar Town, Nishtar Town, Samnabad, Allama Iqbal Town, Wahgah Town, Aziz Bhatti Town, Ravi Town and Data Gunj Baksh Town.

Continue reading Plan afoot to establish nine food streets

Kim Barker Exposes Nawaz Sharif

I was actually going to put up a different post, on Pak-US relations, tonight but some last minute technical glitches mean that post will have to wait another day at least. Meanwhile, the next big political scandal is about to hit the headlines so I thought we could give you all a bit of a heads-up.

Video clip from Mubashar Lucman’s Show:

Continue reading Kim Barker Exposes Nawaz Sharif

Monday, April 25, 2011

Book Review: Untouchables (Escape From Indian Caste System)

Book Review:
Untouchables: My Family's Triumphant Escape from India's Caste System

Untouchables: My Family's Triumphant Escape from India's Caste System, An International Best Seller Not really what I expected, I was looking for a better understanding of the caste system.,April 20, 2011
By Dan K "DPK"
This review is from: Untouchables: My Family's Triumphant Escape from India's Caste System, An International Best Seller (Paperback) I'm Indian but I grew up here in the US and I wanted to learn about the caste system as I was raised Christian and my family does not believe in this backwards tradition. I've heard stories about the caste system but I thought this book would give me a better understanding of it's origins and ideology. 

The book is actually very easy to read and you could finish it off in a day or two. The language is easy to understand and it flows very well. The story being told is the author's translation of his parents recollections during the early 1900's under the caste system in India. The book starts out well and hooks you immediately. The beginning story of how the author's father was beaten and treated as less-than-human really helps you to see how cruel the system is. Unfortunately that is really the only part in the book when you are able to see the cruelness of this system. The rest of the book reads more like a narrative. Somewhere in the middle, I started to lose my interest because I was expecting to see more of this cruel injustice but the author started discussing how his parents were walking on the beach, having kids, and traveling back and forth to Mumbai. That didn't sound like oppression to me. As an Indian, I've visited India and I have seen low caste people get treated like garbage and it breaks my heart because, as Americans, we just can't understand that in this society. I was expecting to understand why they do this in India but I didn't get that in this book. Actually, the first thing that came to my mind was that the way the author portrayed the caste system wasn't nearly as bad as what African-American's had to go through here in the US not so long ago. In reality, I know the caste system in India is far worse and inhuman but the author simply did not portray it as such. 

Sure, the author's parents fought to stand up for what is right and vowed to give their kids a better life but there are countless other people in India who's story is very different. I was thinking I was going to get some insight into that. It's great that the author wrote a book about an untouchable who succeeded and rose above the oppression but I think the story would have been so much more effective if we understood more about what the caste system is all about, why people still believe in it, and why India just can't get rid of it. 

Overall, it was a decent read but I didn't come away with a good understanding of the caste system after reading it. Maybe if you are not Indian, this might be a good starting point but if you are buying this book to understand the Indian caste system, you will be disappointed. 

Also, the epilogue which is written by Jadhav's daughter really didn't add to the book as it seemed more like she was gloating about her accomplishments. I know she was trying to portray that she, living in America, does not have to deal with the injustices that her grandparents had to but it just didn't come across as such. 

I'd borrow this book first. 

A Shutdown of the Mind

Pakistan’s energy crisis, after registering its imprint on the society and economy, is now beginning to target the psychological well-being of its citizens

Loadshedding – most of it unannounced – has now gone to 12-16 hours in urban areas of the Punjab. Throughout last week, Lahore was submerged in darkness, except for a few hours of electricity every now and then. The heatwave in the end of April 2011 is registering around 40 degrees Celsius, and one can only imagine what June and July will feel like this year.

Continue reading A Shutdown of the Mind

Forgotten victims of Pakistan's Taliban war

Shadi Khan was once a proud soldier fighting the Taliban, but today he quivers in pain, socks bagged around metal pins after a bomb blew off his legs on Pakistan’s deadliest battlefield.

His unit had arrested 10 Taliban operatives and killed another eight, and was heading back to base camp in South Waziristan when the bomb exploded. That was August 2010. He is still in hospital.

Read more...

Protests mount against Indian nuclear plant

Protests mount against Indian nuclear plant

SAKHRI NATE, INDIA: In the busy Indian fishing village of Sakhri Nate, it’s obvious what the locals think of the plan to build the world’s biggest nuclear power plant just across the creek.

“Say No To Nuclear Power. We Don’t Want To Get Sick,” reads one slogan in Hindi on the side of a tarpaulin-covered shack selling sweet tea and sugary snacks.

Chalked on a wall around the corner is a message for the French company that has signed a $9.3-billion deal to supply the plant’s first state-of-the-art pressurised water reactors.

Read more...

Nuclear watchdog praises Pakistan's commitment to safety

Pakistan is the 10th largest contributor to the Nuclear Security Fund and it clearly demonstrates a national commitment and serious approach towards nuclear security through the implementation of the Nuclear Action Plan for Pakistan, Deputy Director-General of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) Denis Flory said on Saturday.

He was speaking at the concluding session of the three-day international seminar on Nuclear Safety and Security Challenges of the 21st Century organised by the PNRA in collaboration with the IAEA to mark the nuclear authority’s 10th founding anniversary.

Read more...

Why One Million Indians Escape From India Every Year

Any crackdown on illegal immigrants abroad or restricting quotas to Indians are a major concern to India’s politicians. The latest statistics from US Department of Homeland Security shows that the numbers of Indian illegal migrants jumped 125% since 2000! Ever wondered why Indians migrate to another countries but no one comes to India for a living? Here are some Indian facts:

Poverty Graph

According to WFP, India accounts around 50% of the world’s hungry.  (more than in the whole of Africa) and its fiscal deficit is one of the highest in the world.  India’s Global Hunger Index (GHI) score is 23.7,  a rank of 66th out of 88 countries.  India’s rating is slightly above Bangladesh but below all other South Asian nations and India is  listed under “ALARMING” category.  

Read more...

How Islamic inventors changed the world

1 The story goes that an Arab named Khalid was tending his goats in the Kaffa region of southern Ethiopia, when he noticed his animals became livelier after eating a certain berry. He boiled the berries to make the first coffee. Certainly the first record of the drink is of beans exported from Ethiopia to Yemen where Sufis drank it to stay awake all night to pray on special occasions. By the late 15th century it had arrived in Mecca and Turkey from where it made its way to Venice in 1645. It was brought to England in 1650 by a Turk named Pasqua Rosee who opened the first coffee house in Lombard Street in the City of London. The Arabic qahwa became the Turkish kahve then the Italian caffé and then English coffee.

Read more...

Beaconhouse not paying municipal fees

The Lahore Development Authority (LDA) has not charged the Beaconhouse School System commercialisation fees for at least 10 branches built in residential areas in the city, a ‘favour’ worth millions of rupees, The Express Tribune has learnt.


The Beaconhouse School System claims to be “possibly the largest private school system of its kind in the world”, currently educating close to 200,000 students. It is owned by the influential Kasuri family, which includes former foreign minister Khurshid Mehmood Kasuri. It has around 30 campuses in Lahore, most built in residential areas.

Continue reading Beaconhouse not paying municipal fees

Want to change Pakistan? Try joining the government as an honest bureaucrat!

A Guide to the CSS

In the last decade, fewer and fewer candidates for the CSS (Central Superior Services) exam have passed the gruelling test to join the ranks of that elite layer of bureaucrats that runs Pakistan. Fifteen per cent of candidates qualified the written part in 2008 but only eight per cent could do so in 2009. This is a shame because if you pass the exam, you can provide at least three decades of what can be exceedingly rewarding public service.

Continue reading Want to change Pakistan? Try joining the government as an honest bureaucrat!

Poverty of philosophy

Across the length and breadth of Pakistan, amongst journalists, politicians, generals and even judges, there is a poverty of philosophy that is crippling the development of a stable state and responsible society. From the personal to the political, from the ridiculous to the sublime, this poverty manifests itself everyday in reckless outbursts of remarks, statements and comments that obfuscate issues instead of clarifying them. Consider.

Some well-known journalists have been predicting the end of the Zardari regime for over a year now by regularly giving D-Day deadlines. But President Asif Ali Zardari continues to defy their hollow predictions, prompting Javed Hashmi to wisecrack that a PhD in politics may be required to fathom his brand of politics. Considering how very consistently wrong they have proven to be, one may be forgiven for wondering whether it is lack of intelligence or scarcity of credible sources that lies at the root of their helplessness and rage. Or is it plain wishful thinking and personal vendettas that are masquerading as serious front-page political analyses?

Continue reading Poverty of philosophy

Friday, April 22, 2011

60 minutes of American Fiction

By Fatima Rizvi
Recently, the world was shocked to find out that Greg Mortenson's autobiography 'Three cups of Tea' was based on fabricated anecdotes of his exploits in remote areas of Afghanistan and Pakistan. Mortenson's heartwarming tale of how the simple mountain villagers in Korphe, Pakistan, saved his life after he got lost during a perilous descent of K2, the world's second highest peak; how he repaid their kindness by returning to build them a school; and how he was subsequently kidnapped for eight days by the Taliban are apparently not even close to the truth.

Read more...

SULLEN MULLEN

By Ghalib Sultan

US Admiral Mike Mullen rarely smiles. In fact in Pakistan during his 22 visits no one has ever seen him smile. Not that there is very much to smile about. The NATO/ISAF military campaign in Afghanistan is not going well as the Afghans fighting to oust the ‘invader’ spread their actions to Northern Afghanistan and strike in more and more ingenious ways. To make matters worse after spending billions of dollars the capacity of the Afghan Security Forces (ANA) remains poor and recent killings of US/NATO soldiers indicate that the ANA is penetrated by Afghan Taliban sympathizers. The July 2011 deadline for withdrawal is approaching and even in the areas of surges there is no stability. In fact ‘peace and stability’ in Afghanistan remains a pipe dream.

Read more...


Indian Telecom Giants in Jail!!!

New Delhi: Five corporate honchos spent Wednesday night in Tihar jail after their bail was denied by a special court for their alleged involvement in the 2G scam.

On Wednesday morning, the Delhi court rejected the bail application of Sanjay Chandra, MD, Unitech Ltd and Unitech Wireless, Vinod Goenka, MD, DB Realty and Swan Telecom (now Etisalat), Gautam Doshi, Group MD, Reliance Anil Dhirubhai Ambani Group (ADAG) and Hari Nair and Surendra Pipara, Senior Vice Presidents, ADAG.

Continue reading 2G scam – Top telecom honchos spend night in jail

Homophobic Facebook administration


Two men kissing: too risque for Facebook?

The social network recently removed a picture of a gay kiss for allegedly violating its terms of use, which state, “You will not post content that: is hateful, threatening, or pornographic; incites violence; or contains nudity or graphic or gratuitous violence.”

Continue reading Homophobic Facebook administration

Abuse of Women: Shameless Us!

rape-3-oct05General Pervez Musharraf’s derogatory comments about victims of rape have outraged all sections of opinion in Pakistan and abroad. Women, in particular, have condemned these comments most strongly and have expressed their concern on the prospects of justice for women who become victims of crimes such as rape, honour-killings and other forms of abuse. The remarks were obviously designed to silence those who have dared to make their plight public, and those who have exposed the abysmal failure of the state to protect or deliver justice to victims of violence.

Continue reading Abuse of Women: Shameless Us!

Released Indian and Pakistani prisoners describe trauma



Many of those released by India are reported to be in a poor physical and mental condition



As tensions appear to ease between India and Pakistan following a series of diplomatic “goodwill gestures” during the cricket World Cup, both countries have authorised a series of prisoner releases. So what were conditions like for those who were incarcerated and is there any hope for those still detained? The BBC’s Alastair Lawson finds out.

On the face of it, the prisoner releases by India and Pakistan should have been a time of celebration. But in reality many of those freed say they have been traumatised by their experiences and bitter that their plight was ignored for so long by their respective governments.

Continue reading Released Indian and Pakistani prisoners describe trauma

Only in Pakistan – Some smiles!!!

Some nice and funny pictures from Pakistan

Continue reading Only in Pakistan – Some smiles!!!

Wednesday, April 20, 2011

Tribesmen Sue the Lying Bastard

Greg Mortenson to be sued by tribesmen he said kidnapped him
Greg Mortenson, the author and philanthropist accused of fabricating large parts of his autobiographical writings, is to be sued by the Pakistani tribesmen he claimed kidnapped him.

In his bestselling books about building schools in Pakistan and Afghanistan, one of the most startling stories tells how he was kidnapped by the Taliban and held hostage in Waziristan, the most dangerous part of Pakistan’s western tribal border area with Afghanistan. A photograph in one book showed him with a dozen tribesmen, some armed, who were supposedly holding him captive.

Continue reading Greg Mortenson to be sued by tribesmen he said kidnapped him

The CIA in Pakistan : Not Licensed to Kill

Missile-firing US drones have killed hundreds of innocent civilians in Pakistan

There was a truly bizarre and telling paragraph at the end of a Wall Street Journal news report today on Pakistan’s demand that the US bring home hundreds of CIA and Special Forces personnel operating undercover in that country, and that it halt the drone strikes in the border regions abutting Afghanistan, which have been killing countless civilian men, women and children.

Reporters Adam Entous and Matthew Rosenberg, with no sense of irony, wrote:

The US hasn’t committed to adjusting the drone program in response to Pakistan’s request. The CIA operates covertly, meaning the program doesn’t require Islamabad’s support, under US law. Some officials say the CIA operates with relative autonomy in the tribal areas. They played down the level of support they now receive from Pakistan.

Continue reading The CIA in Pakistan : Not Licensed to Kill

Crumbling Education System of Pakistan

No electricity and too few desks on the first day of matric exams

All earlier arguments over making two students sit at the same desk during the matric examinations seemed absurd on Monday when female candidates at the Waseem Government Girls Secondary School, North Nazimabad Town had to sit on the floor and scribble down their answers.


Several of them had to sit on the floor and in corridors because the school did not have enough furniture for them. As if the routine anxiety of exams was not enough, it was all made worse by load-shedding, uncomfortable — and in some cases insufficient — seating arrangement and delays in question papers at several examination centres.

Continue reading No electricity and too few desks on the first day of matric exams

Three Cups of BS

The world was shocked by a report on CBS’s 60 Minutes this week that accused bestselling author and humanitarian Greg Mortenson of being a fraud. Not only were some of the stories from his book fabricated, 60 Minutes alleges, but the charity that Mortenson created to build schools in Pakistan and Afghanistan never built many of the facilities it has taken credit for. Mortenson’s Three Cups of Tea didn’t, as it claimed, bring education to rural Pakistan and Afghanistan. Its finances are a mess, and the charity does not even seem to have kept track of how many schools it built or how many students attended them.

Continue reading Three Cups of BS

Extremist Hindu Organization Sangh Parivar Challenges Christian Missionaries & NGOs

Large stretches on the highway between Koraput and Malkangiri districts in southern Odisha remain isolated. This highway has been the target of large number of blasts from Maoists. As a result, it is now dotted with camps of the Border Security Force and the Central Reserve Police Force. It is not too difficult to spot the contrasting images here. In pockets, adivasi women wearing vermillion marks on their foreheads can be seen ferrying their children to school.

For a long time, Christian missionaries and NGOs were the only entities that reached out to adivasis in Odisha, Chattisgarh, Jharkhand and Northeastern states, apart from the limited engagement of state governments. But, now another juggernaut is rolling in this ideological melting pot, where the security forces and insurgent groups, like Maoists, have taken well-defined positions.

Continue reading Extremist Hindu Organization Sangh Parivar Challenges Christian Missionaries & NGOs

Monday, April 18, 2011

Media in Pakistan always negative

BY OMAR FAROOQUE,
ON APRIL 18TH, 2011

Media is one of the most important pillars of the state and the image of the nation is solely in the hands of how the media portraits it. This video is a clear example of how the Pakistani media has been ineffective in addressing the real issues and how it has in some instances worked against national security by distorting facts with fiction.

Continue reading Media in Pakistan always negative

Media in Pakistan always negative

BY OMAR FAROOQUE,
ON APRIL 18TH, 2011

Media is one of the most important pillars of the state and the image of the nation is solely in the hands of how the media portraits it. This video is a clear example of how the Pakistani media has been ineffective in addressing the real issues and how it has in some instances worked against national security by distorting facts with fiction.

Continue reading Media in Pakistan always negative

Zaid Hamid Exposes Pakistani Media’s Negative Attitude

BY SAHRISH JAMALI, ON APRIL 18TH, 2011

The Pakistani military is already engaged in a number of battlefronts. In these hard times, it is the sole responsibility of the media to keep the morale of the nation as high as possible. Ziad Hamid argues that the Pakistani media is not acting responsibly enough in playing its due role by giving media coverage to the Baluchistan Liberation army and the Taliban.  He believes that by giving anti-establishment factions more media attention there is a risk of the whole nation’s morale going down and wide scale depression.

Continue reading Zaid Hamid Exposes Pakistani Media’s Negative Attitude

Let’s Crush A Baby!

BY NATHOO RAM,
ON APRIL 18TH, 2011

An Indian ‘baba’, or healer, literally stands on the bodies of little babies claiming that this heals health problems. India also has the highest rate of forced marriages of underage girls, and systematic discrimination against citizens based on caste; women from the lowest caste are routinely raped. Male members of the lower caste are often victims of physical abuse, including death in many cases. These things happen only in India, the world’s largest democracy. The mainstream Indian media and the hordes of American and British journalists based in India don’t see these glaring little scandals because of an official policy carefully crafted to project India as the next superpower that is being groomed to serve western interests in Asia. But occasionally stories like these do come out, thanks to conscientious Indian citizens working for the rights of those ignored by the Indian government.

Continue reading Let’s Crush A Baby!

CIA IN PAKISTAN

BY INAAM.CHANDIO,
ON APRIL 18TH, 2011


No, but sometimes it helps.

Pakistan’s military is demanding that the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) sharply cut back its activities in the country in the wake of undercover agent Raymond Davis’s arrest on murder charges and subsequent release. In addition to scaling back the number of CIA drone strikes on Pakistani targets, Pakistani Army chief Gen. Ashfaq Parvez Kayani has insisted on the withdrawal of all contractors working for the CIA and all operatives like Davis, who are working in “unilateral” assignments, meaning that only one country (read: not Pakistan) is aware of their presence. But since when does the CIA need a country’s permission to conduct intelligence operations? Isn’t the whole point that the local government isn’tsupposed to know they’re there?
Continue reading CIA IN PAKISTAN

The implications for Pakistan

BY ALIZEH KHATTAK,
ON APRIL 18TH, 2011

In a meeting of Nato heads of state in Lisbon last November, it was decided that foreign forces would withdraw from Afghanistan by the end of 2014. The meeting envisaged the handing over of security duties to Afghan forces.

We will analyse this briefly later; we have as yet not thought about what implications this decision has for Pakistan. What will be the impact of this change? What will be the effect of the handing over of security duties to the Afghan National Army (ANA) in the Pakhtun belt of Afghanistan when its current recruitment pattern creates ethnic imbalances?

Continue reading The implications for Pakistan

Media being kept at bay on fake degree progress

BY SUPERMAGSI, ON APRIL 18TH, 2011

The media is being kept in the dark over the progress being made by the Election Commission on the scrutiny of legislators’ educational credentials since the process was taken over by the chief election commissioner two month ago.


The ECP has stopped altogether issuing any press releases in this regard.

Continue reading Media being kept at bay on fake degree progress

Message from Davis: Light ke baghair rehne walo

BY MARYAM RAHMAN,
ON APRIL 18TH, 2011

Light ke baghair rehne walo

Dehshat gardi bardasht karne walo

Aik mulk mein 2 eiden manane walo

Strike mein ghar bethne walo

Har cheez pe Extra tax dene walo

Continue reading Message from Davis: Light ke baghair rehne walo

Thursday, April 14, 2011

Japan's nuclear radioactivity reaches Pakistan

Image001

Japan’s nuclear radioactivity reaches Pakistan


 

The radioactive radiation emissions from the Fukushima nuclear plant are reported to reach Pakistan.

 

According to the Pakistan Atomic Energy Commission (PAEC), small traces of airborne radioactive iodine were detected in Pakistan.


The scientists are saying that the amount of radiation detected in Pakistani air, does not pose a serious threat to the environment so far.

 
Europe, north-western Asia and India have already banned imports from Japan. 

 
A 9.2 magnitude earthquake hit Japan on March 11 that cracked the Fukushima nuclear power plant. Scientists said that the intensity of radiation at the stricken-plant was equal to many atomic bombs’ explosion.   

Wednesday, April 13, 2011

ISI wary of American special trainers over spying fears

Image001
By: Reuters And Shaiq Hussain | Published: April 13, 2011

Image002

Gen Pasha’s request for fewer US trainers reflects ISI’s concerns that Americans are spying on Pakistan’s nuclear weapons programme or having contact with militant groups


ISLAMABAD - Request by the ISI for a cut in the number of US Special Forces trainers working in sensitive regions in Pakistan is due to fears they are also spying, according to Pakistani sources with knowledge of the request, illustrating the extent to which growing mutual mistrust is hampering security co-operation, according to a Reuters report. The request was conveyed when ISI chief General Ahmad Shuja Pasha visited his counterpart Leon Panetta at CIA headquarters on Monday. 

A US military official in Islamabad confirmed that a reduction in the number of Special Forces troops involved in training Pakistanis in counter-insurgency was being discussed. “Throughout the history of the training mission there have been discussions about the force structure and location of the training,” the official said. “So this should not be perceived as a done deal. But it’s something that we’re talking about.” 

The Pakistani military declined to comment. About 120 US Special Forces soldiers are in Pakistan’s northwest to train local security forces in counter-insurgency, but given the increasing strain in the US-Pakistan alliance over the past six months, Chief of Army Staff General Ashfaq Kayani now wants those numbers reduced. 

A senior Pakistani intelligence official would not officially comment on the reduction, but said it might be more about appearances than genuine pique, given the sensitivity over foreign troops on Pakistani soil. “It makes it look like the Americans are here conducting operations,” the official said. Any reduction would impact Washington’s ability to gather intelligence for its drone campaign and Pakistan’s counter-insurgency efforts. 

“We want American Special Forces to come and train our people so we can collaborate, but if they get into other activities we don’t want them,” said an instructor at the National Defense University in Islamabad. He said “other activities” could include spying on Pakistan’s nuclear weapons programme or having contact with militant groups. There is a suspicion among the senior military leadership that Americans troops are gathering intelligence on such groups and not sharing the information, or even actively helping them. 

“The main suspicion is why are they staying after completing their job? Their job was to train the trainers so they should have gone back after that,” another security official said. “But they are over-staying.” The crucial meeting between the intelligence chiefs of the US and Pakistan failed to break the stalemate, as Washington showed its inability to extend firm assurance to Pakistan regarding the withdrawal of CIA operatives from Pakistan, while Pakistan expressed its unwillingness to resume the cooperation suspended since the release of CIA contractor Raymond Davis. After the meeting, a CIA spokesman reportedly said the relations between the two agencies remained on “solid footing”. 

He said, “Director Panetta and General Pasha held productive discussions and the CIA-ISI relationship remains on solid footing.” However, diplomatic circles said despite the four-hour talks being held cordially, with both sides trying hard to iron out differences on contentious issues such as presence of a large number of CIA operatives in Pakistan, the meeting proved to be a “non-starter”.

 

***

 

For your information, consideration and perusal.

 

Best Regards,

 

Shemrez Nauman Afzal

Research Analyst

Spearhead Research

Office # 17, Second Floor, Park Lane Towers,
172 Tufail Road, Cantonment,
Lahore – Pakistan

Ph: +92 42 36622335-6  

Law and order, power shortage impeding GDP growth, says IMF

Image001
By: Amer Sial | Published: April 13, 2011

ISLAMABAD - The International Monetary Fund on Tuesday released a programme note on Pakistan, saying the real GDP growth was unlikely to exceed 2.8 percent during the current fiscal year due to adverse security developments which continue to hurt domestic and foreign investor’s confidence, while electricity shortages continue to prevent the economy from achieving its potential. The IMF programme note said the fiscal policy had been affected by low economic activity and a difficult security environment. 

Delays in tax and expenditure reform and the impact of the floods were expected to keep the fiscal deficit high in current fiscal year. Pakistan’s real GDP growth during the current fiscal year would remain at 2.8 percent of GDP as compared to 4.8 percent in the last fiscal. Inflation was estimated at 15.5 percent as compared to last fiscal level of 11.7 percent. 

Finance Minister Dr Abdul Hafeez Shaikh along with the finance team is on a week-long visit to Washington to attend the spring meetings of the IMF and World Bank. Pakistan is likely to seek a new bailout package after scraping the existing $11.3 billion Standby Arrangement programme.

There’s A Terrorist Catholic Nun On The Airplane!

Catholic Nun Forcibly Removed From Plane for Wearing “Muslim Garb”

DAYTON, OH – Sister Cora-Ann, a Catholic nun from the Our Lady of Grace Monastery in Dayton, Ohio got the surprise of her life yesterday, when she was asked to leave the plane she had just boarded at the Omaha International Airport. “I had just sat down in my seat, and started to thank God for our blessings and recite a prayer in Latin”, she recalled, when one of the passengers sitting next to me called the flight attendant. The passenger was Elizabeth Bennet, who later stated: “It is not that we were prejudiced, but she did seem very suspicious. She was dressed in Muslim garb and just before we were about to take off, she started mumbling something in an Arabian or Talibani-sounding language. What was I supposed to do?” Damien Thorn was a passenger seated in the adjacent row and said: “I knew there was something sinister about her, the moment she stepped into the plane. She was wearing those burqa clothes that you see the Iranian women wearing, and she only had a very small carry-on bag.” The flight attendant responded to the call and asked Sister Cora-Ann for her name, boarding pass and a photo ID.

Continue reading There’s A Terrorist Catholic Nun On The Airplane!

Tuesday, April 12, 2011

Why Pakistan's Taliban Target the Muslim Majority

By OMAR WARAICH / ISLAMABAD Thursday, Apr. 07, 2011

 

Image001

A boy injured in a suicide bomb attack at a Sufi shrine in Dera Ghazi Khan, Pakistan is treated at a hospital in Multan on April 3, 2011.

Reuters

 

Although Pakistan's headlines are dominated by the violent excesses of Taliban extremists, the majority of Pakistanis subscribe to the more mystical Sufi tradition of the country's Barelvi school of Islam. And attacks on their places of worship are becoming depressingly familiar. Last Sunday, two bombers attacked the 13th Century Sakhi Sarwar shrine, near the southern Punjabi town of Dera Ghazi Khan, slaughtering 50 people and injuring twice as many. Mercifully, two other bombers failed to detonate their devices, preventing even higher casualties. Still, it was the deadliest assault yet on a Sufi shrine in Pakistan — and the sixteenth in the last two years.


The Pakistani Taliban swiftly claimed responsibility for the attack, as they have done for each previous one. Pakistan's Taliban claims the mantle of the hardline Deobandi tradition, with many beliefs in common with the austere Wahabism of Saudi Arabia. They regard the Barelvi, who comprise more than three quarters of Pakistan's Sunni Muslims, as irredeemable heretics. The Barelvis favor a more tolerant approach to Islam, promoting a cult of the Prophet and incorporate folkloric traditions such as seeking intercession from rural saints. Sakhi Sarwar, a mystic who is also revered by some Hindus and Sikhs, is said to grant women a son — a local legend that rouses anger among Islam's more literalist adherents, who ascribe such powers only to Allah.

  Tensions between Deobandis and Barelvis have punctuated most of Pakistan's history. But with the arrival of al-Qaeda in the country a decade ago, local militants forged links with the global jihadists, their sectarianism sharpened to accept al-Qaeda's "takfiri" worldview that deems adherents of other strains of Islam as deviant apostates worthy of death.


One reason for the uptick in sectarian-based terror attacks may be that the militants' ability to strike the high profile urban targets that once grabbed global headlines has been diminished by Pakistani military offensives in their strongholds over the past two years. "It has become harder for the militants to strike hard targets," says security analyst Ejaz Haider. "Some lessons have been learned from the previous attacks."


So, the militants have, over the past two years, more keenly focused on sectarian attacks. Traditional Shi'ite processions are now routinely targeted by suicide bombers. In May 2010, two mosques of the minority Ahmedi sect were targeted in Lahore, killing 93 people. And there's been an escalation of bombings directed against the majority Barelvis. After attacks on two of their most prominent shrines, Data Darbar in Lahore's old city and Abdullah Shah Ghazi in Karachi, Barelvis came out on to the streets, wielding weapons and vowing revenge against the Taliban. They did not extend blame to the broader spectrum of Deobandis, perhaps wisely evading the beginnings of a more gruesome sectarian conflict that Pakistan can ill-afford.


Not all Barelvis are the models of peace and tolerance that some have portrayed them to be. It was a Barelvi, Mumtaz Qadri, that assassinated Punjab Governor Salmaan Taseer in January, for his opposition to Pakistan's prejudicial blasphemy laws. The assassination was applauded by 500 Barelvi scholars in a joint statement. And the Sunni Tehreek, a Barelvi militant outfit, rewarded Qadri's family and threatened Taseer's daughter. While they may favor a more permissive vision of Islam, certain Barelvis are quite capable of violence where they feel the Prophet has been dishonored.

The campaign to defend Pakistan's blasphemy laws from reform has, in fact, united Barelvis and Deobandis since last November. Barelvi anti-Taliban rhetoric was also put on pause. "We had seen the Barelvis getting ready to organize a campaign against the Taliban," observes analyst Nasim Zehra, "but they got sidetracked by the blasphemy issue and this was forgotten." Until last month's assassination of Minorities Minister Shahbaz Bhatti, the religious right was able to frequently draw tens of thousands on to the streets.


Sectarian hatred aside, rural shrines are a far easier terror target than the more heavily guarded state and economic targets in the cities. Suicide bombers, especially the teenage boys favored by militants, can often evade notice before they reach the target. A crowded space helps secure the militants' aim of causing high casualties. In the case of the Sakhi Sarwar bombers, they only had travel to a relatively short and unimpeded distance from North Waziristan to the edge of Punjab.

  The bombings may also be an attempt to relieve pressure from sporadic Army actions against militants in the northern tip of the tribal areas. "Just to remain alive there, the militants have to try and force the government's hand into diminishing pressure," says analyst Haider. "To counter that pressure, they mount attacks in the mainland in the hope of securing some deal back in the tribal areas." By targeting shrines across the country, the militants are able to demonstrate their enduring geographical reach and expose the state's vulnerabilities.


The bad news is that the state is in a poor position to respond. After the latest bombings, Barelvi leaders denounced the Punjab provincial government for failing to provide security at shrines. The Punjab government dismisses the charge. "It's happening all over," says Ahsan Iqbal, a leading politician from the Pakistan Muslim League-N, the ruling party in Punjab. "This is not something that is province-specific." Iqbal casts blame on the federal government for failing to share intelligence. The federal government reverses the charge, and argues that the law and order is a provincial responsibility. What no one seems to be focusing on is the desperate need to enhance the police's capacity, with better equipment, counterterrorism training and an intelligence gathering network that reaches deep into Pakistan's remote areas.

Pics of the Day!

Pictures of the Day
6

Bengal Governor R C Casey with his wife and pet in 1943
7

The Founder's Portrait in Lincoln's Inn The portrait hangs in the Great Hall of Lincoln's Inn


8

The Founder lands in Peshawar, June 1948 Followed by Ms Jinnah, Sir Ambrose Dundas Governor and Abdul Qayyum Khan Chief Minister of NWFP and Major General Nazir Ahmed.  Gen Nazir Ahmed was much senior to Ayub Khan. Ayub Khan was only a Colonel or just promoted as Brigadier at that time.   Gen Nazir Ahmed was tall and a man of natural authority. His only son lives in Toronto, Canada. The history of Pakistan might have been different if such an officer had succeeded Douglas Gracey.  


9

The Founder in the Constituent Assembly Just before delivering his historic speech on 11 August 1947. The Establishment later distorted and censored his speech.


10

The Founder in London, December 1946 Talking to the media with Jawaharlal Nehru


Pakistan's Lesbian Detective Series Is Too Hot For India

Pakistan's Lesbian Detective Series Is Too Hot For India

I don't know how things work in India, but I do know that in the United States when groups like the Parents Television Council or Media Research Center attack something in pop culture, it only helps fuel consumption. So I'm curious to see how things play out in the good oldBh?rat Ga?ar?jya, where the 1960s Pakistani pulp fiction title Challawa has been deemed too hot for the Jaipur Literary Festival. Or at least too hot to be read aloud, The Australian reports, because of all the lesbian detective storylines that would, according to the festival's director, violate the "sensitivities of the audience." Which is adorable: An eight-year-old book series revolving around a lesbian (and written by a man) is celebrated in the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, but it's too hot for India? What's all the fuss?

Oh.

The English extract from the Challawa serial - which remains a household name in Pakistan, albeit one mentioned in abashed tones - is the first glimpse into the lusty world of Pakistani pulp fiction.

In the expurgated passages Khan was to read this week, Bano scans for prey on a schoolbus before settling on a fresh-faced 15-year-old "whose breasts met my preference of size and shape".

"I casually put my hand on her thigh and asked; 'Where do you live, baby?' "

"Nasirabad," she responded shyly.

"I liked her shyness. Bold and extroverted girls are usually more delicious in bed, but it's difficult to get them there. The shy ones are easy to seduce." And on it goes.

Altaf Hussain ka Salaam

Altaf Hussain ka Salaam BY INAAM.CHANDIO, ON APRIL 12TH, 2011 After finding out that one of Pakistan’s greatest leaders, Altaf Hussain aka Altaf bhai, was going to send his MQM party to Lahore, I was really excited.

Altaf Hussain is one of the greatest leaders of Pakistan – for the last ten to twenty years, he has ruled Pakistan’s largest city without even being in Pakistan himself! And in the above video, Altaf Hussain conveniently destroyed the entire Two Nation theory upon which the practical existence of Pakistan is predicated, and because of which Indian Muslims had to migrate (i.e. perform Hijrat) to Pakistan and hence become “Muhajir’s” – a so-called ethnicity of post-colonial circumstance. What a great Pakistani he is!
Continue reading Altaf Hussain ka Salaam

Racy Lesbian Pulp Fiction from Pakistan

Racy Lesbian Pulp Fiction from Pakistan “Challawa” to be published in English


BY MARYAM RAHMAN, ON APRIL 12TH, 2011

Steamy lesbian pulp fiction series, Challawa, once a household name in Pakistan, is to be published in English.

Bano’s sexploits, as related in the Challawa series of journals, were bestsellers in 1970s Pakistan, and were seen as mainstream literature.

The heroine of the series, Sabiho Bano, is a wealthy 35 year old Pakistani socialite who has a voracious appetite for young, lower class girls in particular.

Continue reading Racy Lesbian Pulp Fiction from Pakistan “Challawa” to be published in English

MQM in Punjab

BY NATHOO RAM, ON APRIL 12TH, 2011

Lahori’s know all too well that the power of the MQM comes with a price the ordinary people end up paying

Under the auspices of giving all political parties of Pakistan access to all political spaces in Pakistan, the MQM has ventured (again) into the unknown waters of the Punjab. The PML-N – dominant in the Punjab – has restarted its activity in Sindh and Karachi as well, despite threats and challenges, so that it does not appear like a party confined to the largest (and most dominant) province alone. Federal Minister for Information and Broadcasting Dr Firdous Ashiq Awan has said that the MQM should be welcomed for launching its political campaign in Punjab, while cautioning that there was “a great difference in politics” of Sindh and Punjab.

Continue reading MQM in Punjab

Monday, April 11, 2011

Pics of the Day

1

Malik Meraj Khalid with Raja Tridiv Roy Meraj Khalid was Chief Minister of Punjab while Roy was minister for minorities affairs. As Chief Minister, Federal Minister, Speaker National Assembly (for three months) and caretaker Prime Minister (for three months) he proved his integrity, merit, and kept his person above the trappings of power. In fact in his last public office, as Prime minister, he fought a losing battle against the VIP culture, which is throttling us.


2

Supreme Indifference: Nasser with Eden and the UK envoy This was British Foreign Secretary Sir Anthony Eden's only visit to Egypt.


3

Edwina Mountbatten - October 1947 Touring minority camps in West Punjab (Pakistan)


4

John Foster Dulles - A tilt for the military bureaucracy US Secretary of State John Foster Dulles flanked by two bureaucrats; one civilian Chaudhry Muhammad Ali and one military Iskander Mirza in Karachi. He is apparently tilting towards the military man. Ultimately his brother Allen who headed the CIA and John developed a liking for General Ayub Khan


5

A tale of two Secretaries: Sir Anthony Eden with John Foster Dulles in 1956 10 Downing Street - 15 August 1956

Institutionalized Hatred

On April 3rd 2011 suicide bombers hit the Shrine of Syed Ahmad Sakhi Sarwar. The blasts occurred on Sunday during the 942nd Urs (death anniversary) of the Saint and left more than 100 people injured. There were three suicide bombers but out of the three, one of the bombers was unsuccessful in his bid to bring carnage to the peaceful worshipers, and was arrested by the police after his explosives failed to detonate.

Read More: http://goo.gl/YXhDp

DID INDIA ACTUALLY WIN THIS MATCH OR PAKISTAN LOST IT OR WAS IT A WIN-WIN FOR ALL ??

Let us go back and ponder over what actually happened. Those of us, who have seen Pakistan play in WC 2011, know well that this was not a performance from the same Pak team who had performed so well, so far in the tournament.

Look at the following:


1.       Why was Sachin trying to get out desperately?

2.       How many times in his career Sachin has given 7 chances to be out and finally got out on the 7th chance?

3.       Why were his 4 catches dropped?

4.       Why, having reached, a score in mid-eighties, Sachin did not go for his 100th century? Was it that, he was respecting Shahid Afridi’s pre-match declaration that Pak will not allow Sachin to score his 100th ton in International cricket?

5.       Why did Umar Gul bowl so poorly?

6.       Why Abdul Razzak, who has the ability to take Indian bowling to the cleaners, didn’t click and got out to a simple straight bowl from the insipid Munaf Patel?

7.       Why, Misbah waited till the end to show India what he can do their bowling, which he did in the inaugural ICC T20 WC??

8.       Why Misbah hammered Indian bowlers in the 48th and the 49th over, but could not score any runs in the 50th?

9.       Why the Pakis didn’t take the batting power play earlier?

10.   When Shahid Afridi was asked during the post match presentation on the delayed batting power play, his answer was all fumbled which even he doesn’t understand?

11.   Why is it that none of the Pak players, whether in the dressing room or on the field, looked awfully worried that they will lose this match?? You need to see TV replays to understand what I am talking about and compare this with Ricky Ponting and Ozzies’ reactions when they were going to lose to India and when they finally lost.

 

Was the match fixed for money? No. I will not say that because that is a blatant allegation. Then what? The answer is that this match was pre-staged for its outcome embodying political diplomacy at its best. How is that – see below.

 

1.       The Mumbai final would have been a damp squib if India was not in it AND instead the Pakis were playing it.

2.       How could the Indian “AAM AADMI” ( The gullible, simplistic, emotional charged 1.3 billion Indians) allow players from “THAT” country to play on the soil of the same city where just a few years ago terrorists from Pakistan carried out a carnage whose wounds have still not healed??

3.       Political outfits like Shiv Sena would have staged such a dharna that they would have gained tremendous political mileage which would have boosted the otherwise sagging image of their party.

 

Then, what do the Pakis get???

 

1.       The Govts. Of Pakistan and India now get a chance to push forth their bilateral talks which have been suspended since the Mumbai attacks. These talk, though both the Govts. want to push forward, but the GOI can’t do so due to tremendous anger still burning in the hearts and minds of Indian AAM AADMI.

2.       This win, allows the AAM AADMI to “believe” that we have avenged the Mumbai attack as beating Pakis in a WC S/F is like winning a war against them.

3.       The Indian public will now be in a mood to forgive and forget (which we are very good at anyways) the Pakis and will not “condemn” the moves of the GOI to start talks with GOP.

4.       This helps the ruling UPA Govt. of PM Singh which is badly beleaguered with the Tsunami of scams it has been facing as all the attention of the media will now be diverted to this new political development as the country revels in its victory of the 2011 WC.

 

What do the Pakistani Players and the Board get from this:

 

1.       We all know that ICC is a wholly owned subsidiary of BCCI.

2.       BCCI might even allow Pak players to take part in IPL where the big bucks lie and especially that, now the INDIAN AAM AADMI has  “forgiven” them.

3.       BCCI will “PUSH” ICC to allow international cricketing ties between Test playing nations and Pak to resume and to be hosted in Pakistan as that country desperately needs cricket to come back to their soil for their economy; their people and their moods and morale to kick off.

4.       BCCI will push for India/Pak series to be played soon.

 

So Who won and who lost – Everybody won. In the game of diplomacy, there are no losers. The Pakis get what they want; The Indians win the match; The Indian Public has gone bonkers in celebrations; the Governments of both countries can resume their talks and please their big brother – USA. So – Everybody wins and Nobody lost.  

DOCUMENTING PAKISTAN

DOCUMENTING PAKISTAN Posted by Sonya Rehman on April 10, 2011


By Sonya Rehman

Can a Wastern-made documentary on Pakistan avoid the standard clichés?

Last year at an event at Asia Society in New York, Director Cary McClelland spoke about his documentary ‘Without Shepherds.’ I’d never heard about the documentary prior to the event, but I was intrigued when I saw the trailer that evening.

The documentary is based on six Pakistani men and women in light of Benazir Bhutto’s assassination in 2007, and the tumultuous quandary that the country was lodged in.

The star-power of three of the featured individuals (Imran Khan, Vaneeza Ahmed and Arieb Azhar) in the documentary, perhaps gives ‘Without Shepherds’ a bit of an edge, yet, other subjects such as a Peshawari female journalist, a truck driver and an ex-Taliban warrior gives the production an interesting, human dimension.
But while viewing the trailer it made me think back then, is ‘Without Shepherds’ just another documentary churned out ad nauseam, like others, using the typical formula of Pakistani subjects in light of the ongoing ‘war on terror’? Is Pakistan being cashed in on again, given the fact that we’ve been sitting on a troubled hotbed for the past few years?
In February this year, I happened to watch a documentary based on the Afghani arts, culture and lifestyle in Afghanistan. Aired on the BBC, the short documentary featured fascinating clips about spas, hair salons, musicians and female journalists in Afghanistan.


Screen shot from the documentary: Imran Khan

Thankfully, the documentary didn’t dip its toes too deep into the pool of politics, and this resulted in content that was not only richer but infinitely more refreshing. For instance, one clip showed a male Afghan hairstylist sporting a pony tail, while others featured a young Afghani rock band that produces songs in English, to an Afghani female politician who is also a professional singer.

While I’m not propagating an idealistic depiction of Pakistan, I just nurture the opinion that we must break free from this typical surviving-in-the-time-of-barbarity formula. Because it continues to fuel stereotypes. And documentaries stand as productions that ‘document’ history – they are trusted as sources of unbiased information; depicting nothing but the truth. Yet, it’s never always that black and white. Documentaries too, can propagate a certain viewpoint. And that’s what is dangerous in the grand scheme of things that shape mindsets.


Screen shot from the documentary: Vaneeza Ahmed

I trust that there is so much more to Pakistan than terrorism, madness, barbarity. And it is this very trust, and faith, and love of our local arts and culture that has been questioned time and time again by myself.
I’ve felt disillusioned and jaded like many other Pakistanis. The onset of 2011 didn’t help – Salmaan Taseer and Shahbaz Bhatti were both assassinated for a belief and for a purpose that they believed in. And it was this very belief which now lies six feet underground. But the question remains; can a documentary on Pakistan refrain from bringing in the political dimension, just like the BBC documentary on Afghanistan? Perhaps that is an article for another day, but certainly something to ponder on.

In an email interview with McClelland, the Director stated that Pakistan stood as an “ideal country to explore. From a distance, it seemed to be a country of paradoxes – somehow between democracy and dictatorship, peace and war, secular and religious.”


Screen shot from the documentary: Arieb Azhar

He continued; “I relished the idea of doing something that would cut against the typical tropes in the headlines, and spoke from a more intimate connection to the communities there. It seemed the question of ‘where is Pakistan going’ would be more pivotal to the region than any other. Hopefully, we can add some much-needed balance and humanity to the discussion.”
McClelland agrees that during the shooting of the documentary he did encounter some “very natural suspicion people had for an American filmmaker,” but as a liberal American he “would have hated to reinforce any stereotypes and misunderstandings.”

The project, McClelland stated, has been a joint partnership between Pakistani filmmakers right from the get-go.
“We worked with highly professional crews from Karachi, top documentary teams in Lahore, and journalists from Islamabad and Peshawar as researchers and consultants. Even here in New York, our post-production team includes Pakistani editors, sound engineers, translators, experts in community outreach, and more.”

For McClelland and his team, the quest for the subjects in his documentary was a “very organic process.” Pakistani filmmakers and journalists were consulted about the subjects and the content. Imran Khan was chosen as one of the subjects because the crew wanted “the story of the government to be told, but we wanted a fresh perspective, and Imran Khan’s boycott of the election and participation in the Lawyer’s Movement gave us just that.”
McClelland unassumingly admits; “We were outsiders and had a lot to learn about the country before final choices could be made.” Therefore the crew traveled the country extensively in search of subjects and their stories. After identifying their main subjects, the documentary’s filming process was soon put in motion.

“The arts have tremendous potential to balance out this paranoia by promoting humanism and presenting context”, McClelland stated and went on to cite the Pakistani Peace Builder’s Sufi Festival which was held in New York last year, which garnered much positive media attention.

Regarding ‘Without Shepherds’, the Director stated that “the idea has been that the Americans on the team are here to frame the questions that matter most to an international audience, but the Pakistanis were there to provide the answers. Hopefully, when people see the finished product they will agree we did this mission justice.”
For now, the crew of ‘Without Shepherds’ awaits to release the finished product – halted, due to a serious dearth of funds.

Since it hasn’t been released yet, I’ll desist from jumping the gun. For now, I’ll remain humble, and trusting, that the documentary is positive, sensitive and empathetic in its treatment towards Pakistan and its people.

The Express Tribune Magazine